They said that Snowkit was a tabby in Fire and Ice. But then in A Dangerous Path, he's white.
Squirrelflight's milk never came, which is very unlikely. Maybe Hollypaw, Jaypaw, and Lionpaw are the kits of Leafpool and Crowfeather, after their affair in Twilight, but Leafpool was able to hide that she was expecting kits.
As for Longtail, Brokentail, and Onestar:
Longkit, Brokenkit, and Onekit.
Gorsepaw is killed by Tigerstar in The Darkest Hour. And guess what? He somehow came back to life in Dawn, as the warrior Gorsetail. Strange.
Somehow, Rowanclaw's gender changes from a she-cat to a tom.
Why wasn't Rosetail ever mentioned in the allegiances of Into the Wild?
How come so many cats name ends in -tail?
When Hawkfrost says that someone in Thunderclan betrayed Firestar, I think I figured out who it is! Ashfur wants revenge on Squirrelflight, and Firestar is her father. Plus, it was Birchfall as an apprentice who gave Firestar the message, and Ashfur was Birchfall's mentor. He could have easily told Birchfall to say that to Firestar.
Why are kits names usually never mentioned until the become apprentices? And they're never mentioned in the allegiances either.
How come every other clan is tiny, and only Thunderclan has a lot of cats?
In Dawn, Rock Where Snow Gathers is named Rock Beneath Still Water. Bird That Rides the Wind is called Bird That Sings at Dusk. Mist Where Sunlight Shines and Scree have dissapeared, and Jagged Rock Where Heron Sits has mysteriously appeared.
On pages 178 and 179 of Dawn, Tawnypelt is twice mentioned as Tawnypaw. How can you make a mistake that big TWICE?!
